UK: Government promises defamation reform but backslides on expression and surveillance _ARTICLE 19 welcomes the promise of defamation reform in this week’s Queen’s Speech. However, we are concerned that a number of other bills included will unduly restrict freedom of expression in the UK._ The Queen’s Speech, in which the Queen reads the government’s legislative […]
UK: Government promises defamation reform but backslides on expression and
surveillance
_ARTICLE 19 welcomes the promise of defamation reform in this week’s
Queen’s Speech. However, we are concerned that a number of other bills
included will unduly restrict freedom of expression in the UK._
The Queen’s Speech, in which the Queen reads the government’s legislative
agenda for the next parliamentary period in front of both Houses of
Parliament, was this year delivered on 9 May and included a long awaited
Defamation Bill as well as:
* a Crimes and Courts Bill
* a Justice and Security Bill
* a Communication Bill.
The other bills have the potential to interfere with the rights to freedom
of expression, information and privacy.
_Defamation Bill_
This Bill will make it more difficult for dubious defamation and libel suits
to go forward and to succeed. Under the proposed legislation, applicants
will have to prove that they have sustained _serious_ harm: currently, it is
enough just to demonstrate the _potential_ for substantial harm.
Other measures include:
* limiting “libel tourism”
* increasing protection of the media for any publication in the public
interest
* providing better safeguards for operators of websites hosting
third-party content
* offering greater protection from defamation and libel suits to
researchers and academic authors.
ARTICLE 19 endorses these proposed reforms to the current defamation laws:
* the public will have greater freedom of expression
* those who prove that they have sustained harm will receive adequate
protection and compensation
* the media will be able to operate more efficiently and with more
scrutiny on issues in the public interest
* officials and authorities will be more accountable
* website operators will received better protections for content created
by their users and other 3^rd parties. Their inclusion is an important
step towards taking the changing media landscape into account.
_Crimes and Courts__ Bill_
ARTICLE 19 calls for this Bill to be carefully reviewed. It proposes
allowing TV cameras into the courtroom under certain circumstances in order
to increase transparency in the judicial system. It will be crucial to
ensure that the ways of deciding which proceedings can be filmed and
broadcast balance carefully the need to protect witnesses and fair trials
against open justice principles.
The Bill also proposes the creation of a National Crime Agency (NCA).
ARTICLE 19 recommends that:
* the NCA should be transparent and subject to the Freedom of Information
Act (FOIA) 2000
* any exemptions from the FOIA should be fully justifiable through an
independent process. Currently, the Serious Organised Crime Agency has
been exempted from FOIA, but the NCA has a wider remit covering many
traditional policing agencies.
ARTICLE 19 welcomes the reform of the selection process of judges and the
overhaul of processes within reform courts and tribunals. These changes aim
at:
* greater efficiency, diversity and transparency
* a greater understanding of the judicial processes
They should be implemented throughout the UK.
_Justice and Security Bill_
Under this Bill, courts will be given extended powers to hold closed
proceedings when considering sensitive information related to national
security. This evidence will be shared only with:
* the government
* the judge
* the security agencies
* a state-appointed special advocate.
ARTICLE 19 is concerned that:
* the use of these closed proceedings undermines defendants’ right to a
fair trial
* the proceedings pose a serious threat to open justice
* the processes for deciding if information could be deemed sensitive are
poorly defined
* there is a likelihood of closed proceedings being used to shield the
government from public scrutiny.
Such closed legal proceedings constitute a serious interference with the
public’s right to freedom of information and undermines the principles of
open justice and fair trials.
_Communications Bill_
ARTICLE 19 considers this piece of legislation to be highly problematic
because it orders all Communications Service Providers (including Internet
Service Providers and mobile phone operators) to save and store for one year
details of all communications made by all persons in the UK..
Although communications surveillance has a role to play in combating crime,
it should only be used:
* with a court warrant
* when strictly necessary.
ARTICLE 19 is concerned that:
* the stockpiling of information from every person in the UK without any
suspicion constitutes an invasion of privacy which is neither
proportionate nor necessary.
this proposal is more reminiscent of an authoritarian government that
rejects human rights than a democracy that is subject to the European
Convention on Human Rights.
* the proposal will substantially affect the right to free expression, as
it discourages people from visiting controversial sites and makes it
possible to identity confidential sources of journalists
* the proposed safeguards
do not justify the initial surveillance and
stockpiling of data, particularly as data security is poor among police
agencies and private companies such as mobile phone operators, as the
current Leveson Inquiry has revealed.
ARTICLE 19 therefore calls on the government and parliament to reject this
bill, as was done in the last Parliament. _ _
[3]Friend on Facebook
[4]Follow on Twitter
[5]Forward to a Friend
For press queries and interview requests, please contact the press office:
T: +44 (0) 20 7324 2510
E: [6]pressteam@article19.org
M: +44 (0) 7515 828 939
Links:
3.
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1448716238
4.
http://www.twitter.com/article19org/
5. http://us2.forward-to-friend1.com/forward?u=de9f45d125dffa47919a18815&id=ecf38369f4&e=290a5d4aa5
6. mailto:pressteam@article19.org
Like
UK:
Government
promises defamation reform but backslides on
expression and surveillance on Facebook
Links:
1. http://us2.campaign-archive1.com/?u=de9f45d125dffa47919a18815&id=ecf38369f4&fblike=true&e=290a5d4aa5&socialproxy=http%3A%2F%2Fus2.campaign-archive2.com%2Fsocial-proxy%2Ffacebook-like%3Fu%3Dde9f45d125dffa47919a18815%26id%3Decf38369f4%26url%3Dhttp%253A%252F%252Fus2.campaign-archive1.com%252F%253Fu%253Dde9f45d125dffa47919a18815%2526id%253Decf38369f4%26title%3DUK%253A%2520Government%2520promises%2520defamation%2520reform%2520but%2520backslides%2520on%2520expression%2520and%2520surveillance
share on Twitter
Links:
1. http://twitter.com/share?url=http%3A%2F%2Feepurl.com%2FlK8oP&text=UK%3A+Government+promises+defamation+reform+but+backslides+on+expression+and+surveillance+via+%40article19org&count=none
_About ARTICLE 19 _
ARTICLE 19 is an independent human rights organisation that works globally
to protect and promote the right to freedom of expression. It takes its name
from Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which
guarantees free speech.
[7]follow on Twitter
[8]friend on Facebook
[9]forward to a friend
You are receiving this email because you signed up during an event or online and requested updates on freedom of expression and information.
Links:
7.
http://www.twitter.com/article19org/
8.
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1448716238
9. http://us2.forward-to-friend1.com/forward?u=de9f45d125dffa47919a18815&id=ecf38369f4&e=290a5d4aa5
_We can be contacted at:_
ARTICLE 19
60 Farringdon Road
London, England EC1R 3GA
Tel: +44 20 7324 2500
Fax: +44 20 7490 0566
Email: info@article19.org
[10]Creative Commons License
This
work
is
licensed
under
a
[11]Creative
Commons
Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Links:
10. http://article19.us2.list-manage.com/track/click?u=de9f45d125dffa47919a18815&id=b60a414d3d&e=290a5d4aa5
11. http://article19.us2.list-manage.com/track/click?u=de9f45d125dffa47919a18815&id=3990952a7f&e=290a5d4aa5
ARTICLE 19, Registered Charity no. 327421, a Company Limited by Guarantee
registered in England and Wales no. 2097222.
[12]unsubscribe from this list
[13]update subscription preferences
Links:
12. http://article19.us2.list-manage.com/unsubscribe?u=de9f45d125dffa47919a18815&id=c3bf82663f&e=290a5d4aa5&c=ecf38369f4
13. http://article19.us2.list-manage.com/profile?u=de9f45d125dffa47919a18815&id=c3bf82663f&e=290a5d4aa5
Is this email not displaying correctly? View it in your browser .
UK: Government promises defamation reform but backslides on expression and surveillance
ARTICLE 19 welcomes the promise of defamation reform in this week’s Queen’s Speech. However, we are concerned that a number of other bills included will unduly restrict freedom of expression in the UK.
The Queen’s Speech, in which the Queen reads the government’s legislative agenda for the next parliamentary period in front of both Houses of Parliament, was this year delivered on 9 May and included a long awaited Defamation Bill as well as:
a Crimes and Courts Bill
a Justice and Security Bill
a Communication Bill.
The other bills have the potential to interfere with the rights to freedom of expression, information and privacy.
Defamation Bill
This Bill will make it more difficult for dubious defamation and libel suits to go forward and to succeed. Under the proposed legislation, applicants will have to prove that they have sustained serious harm: currently, it is enough just to demonstrate the potential for substantial harm.
Other measures include:
limiting “libel tourism”
increasing protection of the media for any publication in the public interest
providing better safeguards for operators of websites hosting third-party content
offering greater protection from defamation and libel suits to researchers and academic authors.
ARTICLE 19 endorses these proposed reforms to the current defamation laws:
the public will have greater freedom of expression
those who prove that they have sustained harm will receive adequate protection and compensation
the media will be able to operate more efficiently and with more scrutiny on issues in the public interest
officials and authorities will be more accountable
website operators will received better protections for content created by their users and other 3 rd parties. Their inclusion is an important step towards taking the changing media landscape into account.
Crimes and Courts Bill
ARTICLE 19 calls for this Bill to be carefully reviewed. It proposes allowing TV cameras into the courtroom under certain circumstances in order to increase transparency in the judicial system. It will be crucial to ensure that the ways of deciding which proceedings can be filmed and broadcast balance carefully the need to protect witnesses and fair trials against open justice principles.
The Bill also proposes the creation of a National Crime Agency (NCA). ARTICLE 19 recommends that:
the NCA should be transparent and subject to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) 2000
any exemptions from the FOIA should be fully justifiable through an independent process. Currently, the Serious Organised Crime Agency has been exempted from FOIA, but the NCA has a wider remit covering many traditional policing agencies.
ARTICLE 19 welcomes the reform of the selection process of judges and the overhaul of processes within reform courts and tribunals. These changes aim at:
greater efficiency, diversity and transparency
a greater understanding of the judicial processes
They should be implemented throughout the UK.
Justice and Security Bill
Under this Bill, courts will be given extended powers to hold closed proceedings when considering sensitive information related to national security. This evidence will be shared only with:
the government
the judge
the security agencies
a state-appointed special advocate.
ARTICLE 19 is concerned that:
the use of these closed proceedings undermines defendants’ right to a fair trial
the proceedings pose a serious threat to open justice
the processes for deciding if information could be deemed sensitive are poorly defined
there is a likelihood of closed proceedings being used to shield the government from public scrutiny.
Such closed legal proceedings constitute a serious interference with the public’s right to freedom of information and undermines the principles of open justice and fair trials.
Communications Bill
ARTICLE 19 considers this piece of legislation to be highly problematic because it orders all Communications Service Providers (including Internet Service Providers and mobile phone operators) to save and store for one year details of all communications made by all persons in the UK..
Although communications surveillance has a role to play in combating crime, it should only be used:
with a court warrant
when strictly necessary.
ARTICLE 19 is concerned that:
the stockpiling of information from every person in the UK without any suspicion constitutes an invasion of privacy which is neither proportionate nor necessary.
this proposal is more reminiscent of an authoritarian government that rejects human rights than a democracy that is subject to the European Convention on Human Rights.
the proposal will substantially affect the right to free expression, as it discourages people from visiting controversial sites and makes it possible to identity confidential sources of journalists
the proposed safeguards do not justify the initial surveillance and stockpiling of data, particularly as data security is poor among police agencies and private companies such as mobile phone operators, as the current Leveson Inquiry has revealed.
ARTICLE 19 therefore calls on the government and parliament to reject this bill, as was done in the last Parliament.
Friend on Facebook
Follow on Twitter
Forward to a Friend
For press queries and interview requests, please contact the press office:
T: +44 (0) 20 7324 2510
E: pressteam@article19.org
M: +44 (0) 7515 828 939
About ARTICLE 19
ARTICLE 19 is an independent human rights organisation that works globally to protect and promote the right to freedom of expression. It takes its name from Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which guarantees free speech.
follow on Twitter
friend on Facebook
forward to a friend
You are receiving this email because you signed up during an event or online and requested updates on freedom of expression and information.
We can be contacted at:
ARTICLE 19 60 Farringdon Road London , England
EC1R 3GA United Kingdom Add us to your address book
Tel: +44 20 7324 2500
Fax: +44 20 7490 0566
Email: info@article19.org
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License .
ARTICLE 19, Registered Charity no. 327421, a Company Limited by Guarantee registered in England and Wales no. 2097222.
unsubscribe from this list
update subscription preferences
